Cyril’s Fish House

Cyril’s Fish House

#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
#6
#7
#8
#9
#10
2167 Montauk Hwy
Montauk
NY
11954
Montauk
(631) 267-7993

“BBC with a floater.” Learn it. Know it. Live it. (thanks, Brad from Fast Times).  Cyril’s is a roadside bar with the famous Baileys Banana Colada topped with dark rum that’s a must try in the Hamptons.  Having 1 BBC is solid, having #2 is often too sweet, and having #3 = hammered so feel free to have a tasty bloody mary or ice cold beer instead, or the lobster roll to absorb some alcohol.

Most people congregate out front which is our preferred spot, though the younger crew will attempt keg stands in back while the older generation takes up the tables in the middle. Feel free to show your versatility but flowing between each.

When you go, feel free to make it your bachelor party mission to say hi to reggae Cyril, and please send him our best.

Venue Tip: 

If you just want a beer, go around to the right side of the front bar and grab a beer or tip extra big at the beginning to encourage faster service.

The Good: 
A Hamptons staple with the landmark that is Cyril and his fish house. The famed BBC drink is what you go for. A fun vibe and crowd, but can get a little chaotic at peak happy hour times.
The Bad: 
No credit cards + small bar + understaffed + popular spot = long waits.
Vote Up/Down:
Vote Up/Down

Price: $$$

Reservations needed?: To sit at a table, yes, or at least put your name in right away and get there early.

Nearby: Clam Bar, Surf Lodge (kind of), Ruschmeyer's (kind of close)

Attire:  Shorts, Golf shirt, flip flops.  You’re usually there during the day and it can get hot.

Bachelor10 Drink of choice: Excuse me?  Phys. Ed?  You’re out of my room.  Seriously, get out.  Did you not pay attention here?  BBC with floater.

Vibe: Outdoor dive.

Best day: Saturday happy hour.