Nick & Toni’s

Nick & Toni’s

#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
#6
#7
#8
#9
#10
136 N Main St
East Hampton
NY
11937
East Hampton
(631) 324-3550

Nick & Toni’s is a staple in the Hamptons; one of those restaurants that people rave about and should not be missed. Combine excellent food and fantastic drinks with great friends (or at least good dudes you just met for bachelor party debauchery) and you’re good to go.

Tucked away with an interesting mix of seating, it has a little bit of a New Orleans feel to it.  Grab a drink indoors at the bar, potentially rub shoulders with the likes of Billy Joel - who’s been known to sing happy birthday here to an unsuspecting patron (just don't request We Didn't Start the Fire) - and enjoy outdoor seating if the weather cooperates.

Fish, steak, or pasta, it’s hard to go wrong with just about anything you order here.  This Italian/American spot is worth the hefty price, if not calorie count. After all, you'll need the base for your club scene at Georgica or dancing to 80s/90s tunes at Talkhouse.

Venue Tip: 

Let them know ahead of time that you’re a bigger group so they can accommodate you and the bachelor party properly.

The Good: 
You can say you ate at the great Nick & Toni’s, and you’ll thank us later.
The Bad: 
The service can sometimes be slower than you’d like because it’s always crazy packed, so settle in and relax.
Vote Up/Down:
Vote Up/Down

Price: $$$$

Accepts Credit Cards?: Yes

Reservations needed?: Yes. Reasonably long waits if you don’t though there’s a solid bar to ‘prep’ at before eating.

Attire: Casual is fine but it’s on the nicer side so you should step it up a bit.

Best dish(es): We say go for the Rigatoni or Whole fish with a side of corn.

Nearby: Georgica, Talkhouse, Meeting House